Casey Key

N Casey Key Rd
FL 34229
Price Range: $730,000 – $16,900,000
Square Footage: 892 – 13,553 sqft

Casey Key Homes For Sale


About Casey Key

Casey Key, tucked away off the shores of Nokomis, Florida, is like your own personal coastal sanctuary. This slender island, quietly nestled between Sarasota and Venice, has a unique blend of laid-back beachfront living, natural beauty, and a touch of history. Imagine waking up to the sound of gentle waves and the salty sea breeze right at your doorstep. Casey Key embodies the dream of living by the beach, offering easy access to Nokomis Beach, which holds the charm of Sarasota County's oldest public beach. It's the kind of place where you can slow down, relax, and savor the simple pleasures of Florida living.

Key Features of Casey Key

Coastal Paradise

Tranquil Retreat

Beachfront Living

What's Around Casey Key?

Selling Soon? Get Complimentary Nokomis
Market Reports

Buyers are willing to pay a premium for properties in Nokomis—so if you're thinking about selling soon, it's crucial to know where you stand. Just let us know where to send the reports, and we'll send you the most up-to-date Nokomis sold data straight to your inbox.

Get Your Free Market Report!

By giving us your phone number and email address, you are giving Dennis Kotaska permission to contact you via email, phone, or text.

Key Amenities of Casey Key


Nokomis Public Beach on Casey Key is a beloved spot where residents and visitors can savor the sun, sand, and sea. Nearby, North Jetty Park offers opportunities for fishing, picnicking, and boat watching, making it a delightful complement to the coastal lifestyle.

Nearby Entertainment

Marie Selby Botanical Gardens is a captivating botanical garden in Sarasota, just a stone's throw away from Casey Key, renowned for its lush collection of tropical plants and a perfect place to explore the wonders of nature.

Shopping & dining

Casey Key Fish House offers waterfront dining with a focus on seafood, while Deep Lagoon Seafood and Oyster House is another excellent seafood dining option that promises a delightful culinary experience. For those with a sweet tooth, don't miss a visit to Sweet Melissa's Ice Cream Shop, the perfect spot to indulge in delicious ice cream treats.

Public schools

Laurel Nokomis School provides a local educational foundation, while the Island Village Montessori School offers a Montessori-based approach. For those seeking gifted education, Pine View School is renowned for its programs. Additionally, Venice High School is a comprehensive high school nearby, ensuring a diverse array of educational opportunities for students in the Casey Key area.

Casey Key at a Glance

Nokomis Demographics

Population: 19,555
County: Sarasota
Median household income: $144,136

Getting Around

Sarasota: 35 mins
Venice: 15 mins
Sarasota Bradenton Int'l Airport: 43 mins

Find Home in Casey Key

Experience the coastal lifestyle you've been dreaming of on Casey Key. From pristine beaches to exceptional dining and top-notch schools, Casey Key has it all. Let us assist you in finding your ideal piece of paradise. Get in touch with us today to embark on your journey to a life by the sea!